Chunky Y2K running shoes are having a real moment, and two names keep coming up in the same breath: the Asics Gel-Kayano 14 and the Saucony ProGrid Omni 9. Both are archive runners from the same early-2000s era, both lean into that oversized, layered shape, and both started out as serious stability trainers before becoming everyday staples. So which one's actually worth buying?
Here's how they compare.
The short version
- Want the shoe everyone recognises instantly? Go Kayano 14. It's become the face of the whole trend.
- Want something a bit different from what everyone else is wearing? Go Omni 9. Same era, same energy, fewer people wearing it.
- Genuinely can't decide? They both wear well, so it comes down to which look you prefer rather than which is "better".
Where they come from
The Gel-Kayano line is Asics' stability running shoe, built for runners logging serious miles who wanted support and cushioning. The ProGrid Omni played the same role for Saucony, a stability trainer aimed at the same kind of runner, using Saucony's ProGrid cushioning instead of Asics' GEL. They were rivals on the shelf twenty years ago, and they're rivals again now, just on Instagram instead of race day.
Comfort and build
Both are built with layered mesh, overlays and a thick midsole, which is what gives them the "dad shoe" look in the first place. The Kayano 14 tends to feel more structured and firmer underfoot, which suits people who like a supportive, locked-in feel. The Omni 9 generally sits a touch softer and more flexible, so if you find the Kayano a bit rigid for all-day wear, the Omni is worth trying.
Neither is a bad choice for comfort. It really is a matter of which feel you prefer.
Styling
- The Kayano 14 is now so widely worn that it's an instantly recognisable trend shoe. Great if you want to be in on what's popular, less great if you want something with more individuality.
- The Omni 9 has the same chunky early-2000s look but flies more under the radar, which makes it an easy pick if you like the style but don't want the same pair as everyone else.
Both lean into original-era colours, with greys, navy, silver and the odd bold accent, so you can style either with jeans, cargos or joggers in the same way.
Price
Both usually sit in a similar price bracket, with rarer colourways costing more. Check our Gel-Kayano 14 and ProGrid Omni 9 collections for current colourways, sizes and prices.
Which should you buy?
Choose the Gel-Kayano 14 if:
- You want the shoe that's defining the trend right now
- You prefer a firmer, more structured feel underfoot
- You don't mind wearing what a lot of other people are wearing
Choose the ProGrid Omni 9 if:
- You want the same era and look without seeing it everywhere
- You prefer a slightly softer, more flexible ride
- You like having a pair fewer people will clock straight away
Buy both if:
- You've already accepted that one retro runner was never going to be enough
Shop them at Active Fashion
Every pair we sell is 100% authentic, with free tracked UK delivery on every order and Klarna or Clearpay at checkout. Browse the Gel-Kayano 14, the ProGrid Omni 9, or every Asics and Saucony trainer in one place.